Beware of the Sucker’s Rally

Stocks can experience face-ripping rallies during major bear markets.

For example, in real terms the S&P 500 rallied 43% and 42% during the 1970s secular bear market. Similar rallies occurred during the Global Financial Crisis, Tech Collapse and Great Depression.

These massive bear market rallies don’t always happen, but when they do they are like a siren’s call.

Bear market rallies are often called ‘sucker’s rallies’ because they attract investors from the sidelines by making them believe the drawdown is over, only to destroy their capital once the bear market resumes.

How will I know when the bear market is over?

Predicting the markets is a fast-moving, ever-evolving game. Forecasts move with data flow, and so do good investors. This is what makes investing an attractive pursuit – it’s not something you ever really master because the dynamics are constantly shifting. I allow evolving data to change my outlook. I never get married to an idea or forecast. Most importantly, I recognize I will be wrong sometimes and budget risk accordingly. Forecasts are fraught with uncertainty.

With that said, the data points I think might paint the picture of a market bottom may include some or all of the following:

  • Declining inflation (via demand destruction and/or weaker commodity prices)
  • Declining US Treasury yields
  • A shift in central bank policy (away from tightening to expansionary)
  • Significant valuation compression, relative to historical averages, that accommodates potential F23 downward earnings revisions
  • Daily moves greater than +/- 1% become a rarity
  • Stock yields converge with 10yr Treasury yields, helping make stocks relatively more attractive
  • Many retail investors have thrown in the towel

I am not looking for all these things to happen or to happen concurrently. However, I do believe inflation is the number 1 variable to watch. Financial conditions will continue to tighten until inflation is under control.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Comments (